Two people buy a house together in Queens.
Both names are placed on the deed, and each owns a 50% interest. But only one person contributes the $100,000 down payment.
Years later, their relationship ends. They cannot agree on what to do with the house, and one owner brings a partition action to force a sale.
The owner who supplied the money asks a reasonable question:
Do I get my $100,000 back before we divide the sale proceeds?
Under New York law, the answer is potentially—but not automatically.
A court deciding a partition action may consider unequal contributions toward the property's purchase. However, the result depends on the parties' agreement, the circumstances of the purchase, the available evidence, and whether the payment was intended to be reimbursed or was effectively a gift.
Does a 50/50 Deed Mean the Proceeds Must Be Split Equally?
Not necessarily.
The deed is an important starting point because it establishes the parties' legal ownership interests.
When two people own real estate as joint tenants or tenants in common, New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL) § 901 generally permits a qualifying co-owner to seek partition.
If the property cannot practically be divided, the court may order a sale.
Under RPAPL § 915, the court determines the parties' respective rights, shares, and interests.
But determining ownership percentages does not always resolve the financial accounting. For a broader explanation of how ownership interests and financial adjustments can affect a distribution, see our guide on how proceeds are split in a New York partition action.
Partition is an equitable remedy. New York courts may consider whether the circumstances justify adjustments between co-owners before the proceeds are distributed.
That distinction is important when one person supplied substantially more money to acquire the property.
For additional information about the legal process and financial accounting involved in these disputes, visit our New York partition actions page.
Can the Court Give Credit for a Down Payment?
Yes, depending on the circumstances.
In Czernicki v. Lawniczak, 74 A.D.3d 1121 (2d Dep't 2010), the Appellate Division considered a Brooklyn partition dispute involving two individuals who acquired an apartment building together.
One owner had paid the entire down payment and closing costs. The parties disputed whether the other owner had agreed to reimburse him.
The trial court initially directed that the sale proceeds be divided equally.
The Second Department modified that result.
Based on the evidence of the parties' agreement, including their prior dealings, the appellate court determined that the paying owner was entitled to a credit for one-half of the down payment and closing costs, together with interest at the contractually supported rate.
The remaining proceeds would then be divided equally after the appropriate accounting adjustments.
The important lesson is that a down-payment contribution can affect the ultimate distribution even when the parties hold equal ownership interests.
But the decision does not establish a universal rule that every co-owner who supplies a down payment automatically receives reimbursement.
Why Does the Parties' Agreement Matter?
Consider two different situations.
In the first, two friends agree to buy an investment property together. They intend to share the purchase costs equally, but one advances the entire down payment because the other does not have sufficient cash at closing.
The second owner agrees to repay half.
That agreement may support a reimbursement claim if it can be established.
Now consider a different situation.
A person purchases a home with a romantic partner, voluntarily pays the down payment, and places both names on the deed with the understanding that they will own the property equally.
Years later, after the relationship ends, the paying owner argues that the entire contribution must be returned.
That claim requires closer examination. In some situations, the disagreement over financial contributions is part of a larger dispute over whether one former partner can require the sale of jointly owned property. Our article on whether your ex can force you to sell a house you own together explores that issue in more detail.
The court may need to determine whether the payment was intended as an advance, a reimbursable contribution, or a gift.
Simply proving who supplied the money may not answer that question.
What If the Down Payment Was a Gift?
A genuine gift can defeat a later claim for reimbursement.
A February 6, 2026 decision from Richmond County Supreme Court illustrates the issue.
In M.S. v. L.S., 2026 NY Slip Op 50231(U), a co-owner sought credit for a $127,000 down payment she had made when the property was originally purchased.
Although the court accepted that she supplied the money, it rejected the requested credit.
Based on the particular evidence, the court concluded that she had gifted portions of the equity when ownership interests were transferred to other family members.
The court therefore declined to award reimbursement for the original contribution.
This was a fact-specific trial-court decision, not a rule that placing another person on a deed always establishes a gift.
It demonstrates why proof of the original payment and proof of an entitlement to reimbursement are different matters.
How Would a Down-Payment Credit Affect the Money Each Owner Receives?
Assume two unmarried co-owners each own 50% of a property.
One owner supplied the entire $100,000 down payment.
The property is eventually sold, and $400,000 remains after applicable liens and sale expenses.
Without adjustments, each owner's starting share would be $200,000.
Now assume the evidence establishes that the owners agreed to share the original down payment equally, but the second owner never contributed the agreed $50,000.
If the court recognizes a $50,000 reimbursement obligation and applies it against that owner's share, the illustrative distribution would be:
| Owner | Without Credit | With $50,000 Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Owner A (paid down payment) | $200,000 | $250,000 |
| Owner B | $200,000 | $150,000 |
| Total Distributed | $400,000 | $400,000 |
This example assumes the stated agreement is established and no other adjustments apply. It does not represent an automatic statutory formula.
The specific accounting can differ depending on the agreement, ownership interests, other contributions, and court findings.
It is also important to distinguish acquisition costs from money spent after purchasing the property. Down payments and later renovation expenses can raise separate reimbursement questions. For more information about those claims, see our article on getting credit for renovations and improvements in a partition action.
What Evidence Can Help Prove a Down-Payment Claim?
Documentary evidence can be particularly important when the parties purchased the property many years before the dispute arose.
A co-owner seeking reimbursement should consider preserving the original closing statement, bank records showing where the down payment originated, wire-transfer confirmations, and any written agreement concerning the purchase.
Emails and text messages may also establish what the parties intended when they acquired the property.
For example, a message stating that one person would advance the down payment and the other would repay a specified amount may support a different conclusion from communications indicating that the money was being provided without an expectation of repayment.
The history of the parties' relationship may also be relevant.
In Czernicki, the court considered the parties' prior transaction and their conduct when determining whether reimbursement was required.
The practical point is that financial records and evidence of the parties' understanding often need to be evaluated together.
Can the Down-Payment Issue Be Resolved Without a Trial?
Yes.
Co-owners may negotiate an agreed allocation of proceeds rather than litigating every disputed contribution.
For example, they might agree that the owner who advanced the down payment will receive a specified credit before the remaining proceeds are divided.
Alternatively, they might negotiate a compromise that accounts for the property's current equity and their respective financial contributions.
The terms should be documented clearly.
If a partition action is pending, the settlement should also address the necessary court procedures and any existing orders.
Resolving the down-payment issue by agreement may avoid the uncertainty and expense of proving the parties' intentions years after the original purchase.
The Bottom Line
If you paid the entire down payment on jointly owned New York property, you may be entitled to a credit in a later partition action.
But reimbursement is not automatic.
The court may consider the parties' agreement, the evidence of their intentions, their ownership interests, and whether the contribution was intended to be repaid or given without expectation of reimbursement.
A deed establishing equal ownership does not necessarily resolve every financial question between the owners.
At the same time, contributing more money toward the purchase does not, by itself, guarantee that the paying owner will recover that contribution before the proceeds are divided.
For co-owners facing a partition dispute, understanding and documenting the original financial arrangement may be essential to determining what each person ultimately receives.
Attorney Advertising. This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The outcome of a partition action depends on the facts, applicable law, evidence, and court orders.